FB Marketplace Performance Audit — 2026-11-16
Read-only. Built from files already on disk — no browser, no Facebook touched. Window: last 30 days.
1. Listings
Last audit: 2026-10-31T21:06:20.640Z
- Live on Facebook right now: 265
- In current inventory (correct): 130
- Ghosts — live on FB but NOT in inventory, needs mark-sold: 47
- Tracked as posted but gone from FB (stale tracking): 89
- Duplicate listing groups: 9
- Untracked/adoptable (live on FB, dup-post risk if reposted): 60
- Untracked title-ghosts (live on FB, not in our tracked-posted list): 24
Trend vs 2026-09-01: live listings 152 → 265, ghosts 11 → 47, tracked-but-gone 24 → 89.
Read: a lot of ghost listings — FB thinks units are for sale that we've already sold. Worth a mark-sold pass.
2. Posting
Posts in last 30 days: 38 across 7 active posting days (avg 5.4/active day). Last run: 2026-10-31T21:07:55.068Z. Tracked-posted ledger total (all time): 851.
Scan/post-run failures (scan shrank >15%, aborted) in last 30 days: 13. 14-day-dedup skip events logged: 633 VIN-skips (posted recently, not re-posted).
Currently paused FB jobs:
fb-approve: Paused 2026-08-28 by Claude at Will's request: pause ALL Facebook jobs for the moment. rm this marker to resume.fb-audit-live-listings: PAUSED 2026-10-01 07:50 CT by Claude. Facebook warned Will of bot-like activity on 9/30 and the Mini FB browser profile is LOGGED OUT (6:45am audit loaded 0 cards; debug/selling-fail-zero-cards-1790855467388.png shows the Log In page). Do not run until (1) Will logs the Mini FB profile back in himself, (2) at least 48h cool-down, (3) throttle in place: memory/fb-warmup-config.json dailyCap 6, one run at 10am, randomized 5-10 min spacing. Likely trigger: my 9/30 price-edit batch (14 edits in 12 minutes).fb-closer: Paused 2026-09-08 4:40pm CT: Will — Facebook replies are handled by his person; he wants posting/inventory/viewing only, not the draft assistant. Drafts already queued stay for his review; fb-approve/fb-nudge/fb-publish-drafts remain paused. rm this marker to resume drafts-only (FB_CLOSER_AUTO=0 keeps every draft human-approved).fb-keepwarm: Paused 2026-09-28 by Claude (machine-status triage): the fb-keepwarm cron itself was already commented out in scripts/scheduler.ts on 2026-09-25 (100% watchdog-kill rate — see the comment there) but no pause marker was ever created, so memory/scheduler-failstate.json's stale 11-fails-in-a-row entry has been rendering as NOT WORKING on every status view since with no way to self-clear. This marker just makes that already-made decision visible consistently. rm this marker (and re-enable the cron block) only together, if fb-keepwarm gets its own browser profile or a longer timeout in the future.fb-mark-sold-bulk: PAUSED 2026-09-30 23:20 CT by Claude (overnight audit). 11 live truck listings currently carry a wrong 2020 Honda Accord EX-L title (price-edit bug 9/30). The audit classes them as title-ghosts and this job would mark all 11 Sold at 6:45am, then the poster would re-list them and create duplicates. Unpause after the 11 listings are repaired (list: reports/fb-accord-repair-2026-09-30.md). Cost of the pause: real ghosts (2 as of 9/30) stay listed until then.fb-nudge: Paused 2026-08-28 by Claude at Will's request: pause ALL Facebook jobs for the moment. rm this marker to resume.fb-publish-drafts: Paused 2026-08-28 by Claude at Will's request: pause ALL Facebook jobs for the moment. rm this marker to resume.fb-safe-post: PAUSED 2026-10-31 CT by Claude (Build) on Will's OK 10/31: Facebook posting moved to Muse (Juno). The Mini poster and Muse both posted to Will's personal profile and double-listed units. Unpause = remove this file (Will OK).
Throttle/scan-shrink incident days in last 30 days: 7 (2026-10-20, 2026-10-23, 2026-10-24, 2026-10-26, 2026-10-27, 2026-10-28, 2026-10-29).
Last known-good scan: 265 cards at 2026-10-31T21:06:21.950Z.
3. Buyer messages
Buyer threads (last 30d, by first-seen): 0. Threads with zero replies from us: 0. Reply ratio: n/a.
Median time-to-first-reply where we did reply: n/a (no replies with matching data).
Last thread activity recorded: 2026-09-08T20:27:44.489Z. fb-closer has been paused since 9/8 — Will's person answers by hand, so this state may be stale.
4. Leads
FB Marketplace leads in VinSolutions, last 30 days: 2 (all-time in file: 56).
Outcome breakdown: Lost: 2.
Sold matches (gcid → vs-sold.json, or name → axcessa-cardeals.json): 0.
5. Ratios Will asked for
Success ratio (posted listings with ≥1 buyer message / posted, 30d): 0% (0 of 38).
Apply ratio (buyer threads that turned into a VS lead, best-effort VIN/name match, 30d): n/a (0 of 0).
Listings-per-sale: no FB-sourced sale matched in this window — can't compute.
6. What blocked posting
- 2026-08-11: duplicate postings reported by Will — fb-marketplace-drip-poster paused, superseded by fb-safe-post (10/day cap, dedupe) since 8/28.
- 2026-08-28: Will requested ALL Facebook jobs paused (fb-approve, fb-closer, fb-nudge, fb-publish-drafts) while a calm-profile plan was put in place.
- 2026-09-05/08: Facebook replies ruled human-owned (Will's person) — fb-closer stays draft-queue-only; posting + audit keep running.
- 2026-09-16 to 2026-09-18: repeated scan-shrink throttle — Marketplace 'you/selling' page rendered as few as 5-46 cards vs 142-162 expected, aborting posts to avoid re-listing sold units (see section 2 failure count).
- 2026-09-20: JOB SILENT alert on fb-audit-live-listings (last ran 5.2d ago per scheduler) — audit cadence gap, not a posting block.